Home arrow Forums arrow EggHead Forum
SPECIAL EVENTS    
*** NEW - The Texas Pete Ultimate Tailgate Contest ***
The Texas Pete Ultimate Tailgate Contest
EGGFEST CENTRAL    
*** NEW! - Sunshine State Eggfest - March 12 & 13, 2010 ***
Sunshine State Eggfest - March 12 & 13, 2010
Egghead Forum
Egghead Forum
::post new topic::
Am I overcooking?
Date: 2007/11/06 13:53 By: Newbie Status: User  
 

Junior Egger

Posts: 33
graphgraph
I have had my large BGE for about a month now and love it. Several things have been great (mainly items that cook in short periods like steaks). My problem is when I am trying to smoke things over a long period of time. I am not sure if I am overcooking or not cooking long enough.

A co-worker of mine that has had a BGE for several years told me that if the temp stays low enough, "you can't overcook it." Here is what I have done and the results so you can judge / make recommendations.

1. 5.5 lb Pork Butt with dry rub over night. Cooked / Smoked for 14 hours at 225. The last 2 hours were wrapped in foil with juices. I was never able to pull it apart. It ended up chopped and the meat was very "done." No pink (other than the smoke ring).

2. 4 racks of baby back ribs with dry rub over night. Cooked / Smoked for 6 hours at 225. Meat was not falling off the bone.

3. 3.5 lb Beef Brisket Flat Cut with dry rub over night. Cooked / Smoked for 12 hours at 225. Last 2 hours wrapped in foil with juices in a warm ice chest. Meat was done all the way through and very tough.

I think I am over cooking. Other BGE owners tell me to cook it longer and lower the temp to 200.

What do you experts think?

Thanks!

Click here to see the profile of this user reply | quote


    Topics Author Date
  thread link
Am I overcooking?
Newbie 2007/11/06 13:53
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
fishlessman 2007/11/06 14:01
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
WessB 2007/11/06 14:08
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Darnoc 2007/11/06 14:13
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Newbie 2007/11/06 14:17
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
AZRP 2007/11/06 14:23
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Ryan is a loser 2007/11/06 14:25
  thread link
thread linkthread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Newbie 2007/11/06 14:27
  thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
stike 2007/11/06 14:31
  thread link
thread linkthread linkthread linkthread link Re: bwaahahahaaaa!!
AlaskanC 2007/11/06 21:11
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
gdenby 2007/11/06 14:48
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Darnoc 2007/11/06 15:07
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Chuckgga 2007/11/06 15:20
  thread link
thread linkthread link Re: Am I overcooking?
Essex County 2007/11/06 17:01
  thread link
thread linkthread linkthread link Re: Definitely calibrate the dome thermo
Beanie-Bean 2007/11/06 18:29
::post new topic::